It’s already a time ago since I left Myanmar when I write this article but i still don’t really know what I should think about this country with this two faces. When people find out that I was in Myanmar, they usually are very interested and ask a lot of questions but I still don’t really know what I should answer. Myanmar is different from all the other countries in SE Asia and maybe different from all other countries in the world (even if there are worse examples), and it’s hard to grasp and to describe if you didn’t see it by yourself. Should you see it by yourself ? I’m not sure. Before I made the decision to go to Myanmar I thought a lot about that and it was not an easy decision. Now I’m thinking again. Would I go again to Myanmar ? Probably yes, but now I know about some more aspects I didn’t think about before. The country is beautiful, the people wonderful, the athmosphere is different, the culture is impressive but there is much more beside that. Myanmar depressed me in a way. For me it’s a country with no hope, poverty is ubiquitous, fear is a normal part of everyone’s life and visible progress you can only see where the generals live. Let’s face it: The country is fucked up and it won’t get any better in the next decades. It doesn’t matter if the military junta announced free elections for
this year, nothing will change. The dictactors who are in charge now are just too powerful and they have a huge army behind them, plus countries like China and Russia which backup the whole cruel system. And with this big allies nobody dares to make an effort to change something in this country and I really doubt that Russia and China will kindly ask Myanmar to stop human rights violations as long as this countries provitate from the military junta, too. Russia and China (and India, Germany, Great Britain… the list is long) need the corrupt and unscrupulous generals to exploit the rich resources as much as the military government needs Russia and China to keep up the current system where a few people become rich and the big majority suffers. And that won’t change in the next 20 years, I’m sure. It’s hard to travel through a country like this, especially when you meet and get to talk to the people who have to live in this circumstances. It’s not their default that the situation is like this and they are as helpless as you are, what and that makes me feel bad, sad and pity for this suffering country. But I guess for me it was the right decision to go, even if I can’t talk in superlatives about this Myanmar. It’s an experience and it will broaden your mind. It scares you and it makes you feel powerless, it reminds you that you are just a visitor and that you can do almost nothing, that you are not even a drop in the bucket. Off course a visit to Myanmar will make you aware of the situation, and you will tell people what’s going on there, how it looks like and how it feels and maybe other people will be more aware about the situation in the country, too, but under the line… will it change something about this solid and established cruel government ? I have not a lot of hope…
Anyway, my last week was a little bit disappointing and boring. From Shwebo I went back to Mandalay but left the city again in the same evening with a night bus to Kalaw, another major trekking hub in Myanmar. The bus ride
was funny, the bus was a cargo bus that was half full with lumber and some useful stuff which was all crammed in the back of the bus. And how they packed it… unbelievable, without rhyme or reason they just stuffed the things in the back, one hard break and I’m sure the half of the things would decapitate a few passengers. Good luck that my seat was in the last row just before this thrustworthy stowed goods… but, like always, we made it without any bigger problems, the bicycle above me just fell on me once, and we arrived in Kalaw in the wee hours. I found a guesthouse very quickly and the first guy I saw there was Alon from Israel with whom I was hanging around in Yangon already. Usually you should go hiking in Kalaw but as I am not the guy who likes guided tours and every other traveller in town didn’t have the guts to hike to Lake Inle (around 50km) on their own, I cancelled
my plans. To go on a several days trek through difficult terrain just by myself was a little bit too risky, for me, too. But the town is quite nice and the climate refreshing so I just relaxed a bit, watched movies on my laptop and enjoyed a few beers with Alon and fellow travellers in the evening. After three nights I went on to Lake Inle, THE tourist attraction in Myanmar. The best thing about my trip to this place was the drive to there on the roof of a van. That’s style! The lake and the nearer sorrounding villages disappointed me a bit but I was there just for one day before my night bus to Yangon brought me in 14 hours back into the capital. I was kind of happy to be back there and to leave the country two days later after 28 days in general because, as I mentioned, this country was kind of depressing. The last two days I spent the most of my time on the veranda of the guesthouse and only went out to get food and for a visit to the cinema (Avatar, omg what a shitty movie! But it cost less than 1US$, so it was alright) before Air Asia brought me back to Bangkok in the morning on the 5th of February.
Archiv für die Kategorie ‘Burma/Myanmar’
My last week in a country without hope
Sonntag, 07. Februar 2010Myanmar’s hospitality at it’s best, plus spies.
Montag, 01. Februar 2010I left Hsipaw early in the morning to reach Shwebo, a small but historical interesting city 120km north of Mandalay, in the same day. I really didn’t want to spent another night in Mandalay. It worked out fine and I got into one of the numerous shaky buses that connects the two former burmese capitals with each other in a bumpy 3 hour ride. Usually Shwebo is not on the tourist map at all and I probably wouldn’t go there, too, but at the Shwedagon Paya in Yangon I got to know a nice english student named Jerry who invited me to his hometown. He expected me already at the bus station and was really excited that I really came to visit him and his hometown so he took a two-day timeout from work, borrowed a car and developed a big sightseeing plan for me, what I really
appreciated due to my limited time that I was able to spent there. Unfortunately the government forbids local people to host foreigners so I checked in the only hotel that is open to tourists in town. It was really overpriced but Jerry insisted on paying the half of my accomodation (and every fucking expense that I had in the next two days – no discussion about that possible), so it was for me. What can I say about these two days? It was awesome, but with unpleasent sideeffects, too! The really positive thing was the time that I spent with Jerry. I met almost all of his friends and family members and spent the days with him cruising around from one sight to the next. In the evenings we either watched a movie (when there was no power cut), hung out in one of the few small beer stations or had great food.
For the negative thing I was just waiting to experience it in Myanmar and on the second day in Shwebo it finally happened: We recognised that government spies followed us. How we recognised that? It was not really difficult, always when we left one place someone who followed us before he approached Jerry very unsuspicious and asked him where we’re heading next and, oh surprise, at our next destination there were already people waiting for us. It became really obvious when we (or better Jerry) was warned that it could be dangerous for him to show around foreigners without an official tour guide license by a very harsh and unfriendly casual dressed man who finally showed his police ID after Jerry got into a discussion with him. It ended that Jerry had to drive home to get a 5$ note to prevent himself from further trouble. In the meanwhile when I was waiting for him I couldn’t hold back and began an angry discussion with this asshole (who spoke very good english), too. Probably not very smart in this country but in this situation it was just not possible for me to act different. Good luck that this didn’t result in
any consequences for me. After this nice little meeting we went to Jerry’s old university and, another surprise, a handful of men showed up out of nowhere when we were just about to enter the campus and hindered us from doing so. Later when we bought my bus ticket back to Mandalay another guy came with a pen and paper to Jerry and asked which bus I take and where I go to – insane! As much as I would have loved to hang out with Jerry for a longer time I was very happy when I finally left Shwebo, to have spies following you all the time just made me feel very very uncomfortable. Otherwise Shwebo is a nice city with a some nice pagodas, a monk who died 30 years ago and transformed into stone together with two trees, a nearby nice lake and cobras. Unfortunately I didn’t see snakes but the cities reputation for monster cobras is well-known all over Myanmar. “You go to Shwebo? Watch out for cobras, bro!”
Thanks Jerry for your great hospitality!
I survived Asia’s craziest road!
Montag, 25. Januar 2010I was happy, more than happy, to leave Mandalay with the 4.30am train to Hsipaw after three days. The train takes much longer and is as expensive as the bus but the experience is worth the effort. I booked a 2nd class ticket but when I arrived the station the whole 2nd class, inclusive my seat, was already packed with families and luggage and I didn’t want to chase them away so I boarded the 1st class, prepared to pay a supplement. Maybe it was because my ticket for foreigners was written in english only and the conductor didn’t understand what it sais or he just didn’t care but I didn’t pay more for my cushioned seat. The eight hours (for 200km) were a little bit rickety but the landscape outside was really nice and I had a good conversation with a monk who sat beside me. The highlight was when the train passed the Gokteik Viaduct, a steel bridge over a gorge out of the colonial era that was the
Hsipaw is a nice small city in the mountains, with a comfortable climate (not soo superhot in the day and pretty cold at night) and great surroundings. It’s only a twenty minutes hike and you’re in the middle of the mountains, just surrounded by rice paddy fields, rural farmers, small water streams and water buffaloes. I did some nice walks out into the countryside in my first two days, before the real adventure
started. Ian, a guy from the USA and me rented motorbikes and planned to do the “Namhsam Circle”, a route that is famous for it’s unbelievable bad “road” conditions.
Guidebooks tried to warn us to take this route, for example the Lonely Planet sais about Namhsam: “…a few brave souls come here by motorcycle, but the road is long, the route confusing and you have to break the journey overnight. … There are no permit restrictions for visiting Namhsam town and hiking to nearby villages, but the shocking condition of the road and the unreliable transport links deter all but the most dedicated travellers.” Not us! If the LP sais something like this, you should go and do that all the more.
Equipped with a handdrawn map provided by Mr Bike, the only guy who rents motorbikes in Hsipaw we started in morning. After a few kilometer Ian’s chain jumped off the first time and the 2nd, 3rd and 4th time should follow until we broke down directly in front of a motorbike repair bamboo hut For 0,50US$ the guy fixed the problem in a few minutes and we continued. The road is paved for the first 20kilometer, until you take the leftturn to Namhsam, from there on, for the next 200km, the full Namhsam Circle (this name is an invention by Ian and me – it’s not commonly known like this) it’s
just a more or less narrow, bumpy and rough dirt track. And you shouldn’t have any illusions that the road conditions will be better at some point: No, they just become worse! After the intersection to Namhsam it really starts to be frightening and challenging, I can’t really describe how bad the road is, because even if I tell you that it’s the most terrible road you can imagine, you can’t imagine it, you have to see it. Before this road the worst “road” I’ve ever seen (with a four wheeled jeep!) was the way to the Naiman Nuur lakes in Mongolia, but I’m really sorry for this adventurous way, it’s no longer the number one. Congratulations instead to the Namhsam Circle, with flying colours you’re my official number one of the worst roads I’ve ever seen.
In the first hour you only think “Oh my god, I’ll never survive that” before the adrenaline kicks in and it starts to make fun. You have to be fully concentrated and mistakes are punished immediatly. Ian fell 4 times in the 200km, luckily I could avoid that. Beside the road conditions the landscape is beautiful. The area really earns the nickname “Asian Switzerland”. It’s pretty comparable to the Yunnan area around Dali and Lijiang in China, it’s anyway not really far away (to the chinese border it’s maybe 100km) from there. The area is a tea plantation zone what is
responsible for the miserable street condition, too. The tea harvest is in the middle of the rainy season when a lot of overloaded trucks queue up this windy road and get stuck what results with ruts that are sometimes 1,5m deep. The sleepy village of Namhsam lies on the halfway in the circle and is a logical stopover point because there’s a very basic guesthouse. The village is pretty nice but pretty boring, too. It completely shuts down by 7pm so better have dinner before that
As I said the guesthouse is very basic and ideal if you don’t want to sleep. The walls paper-thin and you can hear every noise from your neighbours room (in my case it felt like a strong snoring chinese man is lying directly beside me), but the thing that was really a pain in the ass for me that night was, that I had some stomach problems and had to use the toilet a few times. Of course there was no electricity and the toilet was one of the squat version toilets, really not convenient when you just have light from your mobile phone. When I ran out of toilet paper after my second visit I had to become inventive… I spare you the details! ![]()
The next day I felt already a little bit better but actually I had no choice rather than to go on the motorbike and ride back to Hsipaw. But it worked. The road was even getting worse than the day before but after an hour the adrenaline kicked in again and we finally made it back to Hsipaw in 7 or 8 hours. Inbetween we stopped in a Palaung village for lunch. The people on the way are really great anyway, everybody shouts “bye bye” to you (strange, everywhere else in Asia they shout “hello” but in Myanmar everybody shouts a friendly bye bye) and waves. Especially the children of course are getting crazy when they see you. When we finally got back on the paved road we both intuitively raised our fists. It was an adventure and it was really great but it’s just recommended for experienced drivers, if you think you are experienced enough to do that, go for it. Namhsam and the whole area is probably one of the most off-the-beaten-track destinations you are allowed to go to Myanmar, really unspoiled and beautiful, so don’t miss it!
When we arrived at our guesthouse, where Mr Bike was already waiting for us, we asked him how many people rented motorbikes and did this trip on their own so far. He answered: “Oh, not a lot, I think maybe 5!” . Somehow that was not really surprising for us.
Anyway, we both thought that it is a little bit irresponsible from Mr Bike just to give us the motorbikes and let us go to do the circle. He knew where we wanted to go and he knows about the conditions but didn’t ask any questions if we have a license, how experienced we are etc. If a usual backpacker who rented a motorbike in Ko Phangan where he went around the island for a day without any accidents and now thinks that he’s able to ride a motorbike and he can manage it to go up to Namhsam, than I simply predict his death on this route. For example, Ian, the american guy, lives in Asia since 8 years and drives a motorbike since 8 years without any accidents. In this 200km he fell 4 times, good luck that he always was on a pretty low speed and nothing serious happened to him. And I was just lucky. If the trip would have been longer, let’s say three or four or five days it would have been just a matter of time when I would have to pick up the motorbike from the ground, too.
We were pretty proud that we did and survived the circle and Mr Bike was somehow, too, and invited us for dinner with his family the next evening. I usually planned to lefave already the next day but this dinner invitation was a good reason to stay one more day and to relax (my asscheeks definitely needed a break, too).
My advice for Mandalay: Skip it!
Freitag, 22. Januar 2010The overnight bus ride from Bagan to Mandalay was kind of pleasent, except the usual inconveniences like a much much too cold air-con, just one break in 8 hours and the arrival time at 5 o’clock in the morning. But otherwise the bus was half empty and we had a lot of space. Actually, it was the first time at all that I had an overnight bus ride in Asia where a seat was free at all.
Thanks to Rudyard Kipling and his “The Road To Mandalay” this city has the image to be Asias most traditional, timeless and alluring place. It’s not. It’s just a horrible city, probably the city I liked least in the world so far. It has some attractions but other cities in Myanmar have them too and in general it’s just a booming economical city that provitates from it’s strategical good position. All trade Myanmar does with China is going through the city and it feels just like a huge dirty marketplace. I usually like
dirty cities (Yangon is a dirty city, as well) but really not this kind of dirty. The whole city somehow looks the same everywhere, nothing special to see and just a few special things to do. Of course there are big temples to visit but there are big temples to visit everywhere in Myanmar. In my opinion, the only really good thing here are the famous “Moustache Brothers”, a comedy troop that is openly dissident to the government. Two of the three brothers were arrested and sentenced to years of hard labour not just once but they don’t think about to stop their program. They are very popular in Myanmar and the government maybe fears protests if they would stop the show so they let them criticise on a low level. Today the shows are just open to tourists, not to locals and in english, not burmese.
But beside all that, Mandalay functions as a hub to a few other old royal cities like Sagaing, Amarapura, Inwa and Shwebo. In the three days I’ve been in Mandalay I’ve just been to Amarapura, nowadays just a small city at the shores of the Thaungthaman Lake. The biggest attraction here is with no doubt the “U Bein Bridge”, the longest
teakwood bridge in the world. It connects the Thaungthaman village with Amarapura and still is very frequent used by locals. BTW: Officially, if you visit the U Bein Bridge you have to buy the 10US$ combo ticket (the money goes directly to the government), but nobody checks. The combo ticket is necessary for a few sights in and around Mandalay but beside the Royal Palace, nobody cares about it. Travellers who try to act a little bit responsible in Myanmar will skip the Mandalay Palace anyway. It’s not the original Mandalay Palace which was destroyed in the World War II. The Palace today was build as a tourist attraction in the late 90s by the government and they used forced labour to build it.
Just skip this city, or stay there only for a day to see how terrible it is or use it as an accomodation point for the cities around. Leave early in the morning and come back in the evening. I know that I was not in the best mood in the days when I visited Mandalay and maybe reached my first real “down point” on my travels but I didn’t meet one single fellow traveller who liked Mandalay, either.
The longest sun eclipse in history at one of the most mysterious places in the world
Dienstag, 19. Januar 2010I don’t know what came into my mind when I agreed to take a chair in the middle row in the bus from Yangon to Bagan because all other seats were already booked. The journey should take 16 hours and I knew that a chair in the middle row usually means a small plastic chair with the height of 30cm. Prepared for the worst overnight bus ride in my life I started together with a few other people from my guesthouse in a shared taxi to the long distance bus station, which is located 45 minutes north of the city center. Then, when I got my ticket and my seat number I was really happy because the middle row seat was just the middle seat in the last row of the bus, good luck. But it could have been a plastic chair seat in the middle row, too, as they filled up the real middle row with this. Business as usual in Asia. The trip was surprisingly pleasent and it took just 11 hours instead of 18 (maybe they tell you 18 because that’s the usual time the bus needs inclusive calculated breakdowns etc.) and we passed through the new build capital of Myanmar, Nay Pyi Taw. It’s unbelievable to see what’s happening there. The whole country is in a miserable condition and the capital is so hyper-modern, super-resource wasting and out of all limitis. 25000 people live there at the moment, mostly army generals and their families. Of course they need 3 lane wide (in both directions!) streets that lead through the city and of course the lanes must be separated by fancy neon green lights instead of simple road marks painted on the streets, of course the whole city must be as bright in the night as it is in daytime and of course every single house you see must look like a palace. It’s insane and when I passed through and started to think about the people in Yangon who are suffering for these corrupt electricity policies, I
immediatly got angry and started to think about a guerilla war to stop this horror junta. Beside that and the two police stops, where we had to get out of the bus to let them control and copy our passports, the way was very convenient.
Anyway, we arrived pretty early in Bagan (as every night bus in Myanmar does) and let a bunch of trishaw drivers bring us to the “Winner Guesthouse”, that I highly recommend to fellow travellers. It’s maybe not the cleanest (but still clean enough) and not the most comfortable one in Bagan, but it’s the cheapest and for sure the one with the friendliest and most helpful owners. For example, usually you have to pay a 10US$ entrance fee for the “Bagan Archeological Zone” at your guesthouse but when we ask them how they handle it, they just ask if we already paid the fee somewhere and then made us understand that we should be quiet and maybe no one will notice. Very nice, really no one noticed. We also checked in at 4am, got our rooms and didn’t get charged for this night or half the night as most of the other guesthouses in Myanmar would do. The rest of the day I spent with sleeping, eating and writing blog articles, so I didn’t went into the fields that day. Another interesting thing happened when we (that were actually Cyril from France, Johannes from Germany, Alon from Israel and me – we shared two twin rooms in the guesthouse) had some food in a restaurant and a man somehow got involved into our conversation. Pretty fast he changed the topics, lowered his voice and started to tell us about the situation in his country and about politics. Stuff like that is really
dangerous for locals, the stuff he told us would mean a few years prison or hard labour for him. It was obvious that he wanted to talk but felt uncomfortable in this restaurant, so he invited us for tea and fruits to his home the next day. Of course we were more than happy to accept his offer.
On day two we borrowed bicycles and biked to New Bagan, the village that was forced by the government to move from Old Bagan to it’s new location a few kilometers out of the Archaeological Zone around ten years ago, to make space for tourists. The old man who invited us the day before, lived there with his family. He already expected us together and after we introduced ourselves to all his relatives we were asked to sit down in a very basic bamboo hut. They served us tea and fresh fruits and the man began to tell. He told us a lot and without a lot of interruption from our side he talked for maybe two hours. He started with the long history of Myanmar and all the different tribes that are at home there and continued with the recent history, which was the the biggest part of his story. He actually didn’t tell something that was really new for me but it was still great to hear all that
from a local. The most interesting things he told us were about the situation in the villages, especially in the villages where tourists are not allowed to go to. Later in this blog more about that. The rest of this day we spent cycling around the temples, what I didn’t really like. I mean, I loved the temples but to go with a bike was just not the right form of transportation for me. It somehow felt to fast, you pass by so many temples and don’t really get the feeling for this place so I decided not to rent a bicycle anymore and to walk around Bagan in the next three days.
What is Bagan about? It’s a unique place on planet earth and it’s one of the most important religious sites in the world, as well. It’s the most important national heritage of Myanmar, it’s amazing, stunning, mystical. In numbers, the first temple in this old royal city was built in 1057 AD and around 4400 temples followed in the next 230 years before a few
thousand mongolian warriors, sent by Kublai Khan, swept through the city and ended Bagans glory days. At the end of the 13th century Bagan counted 4446 temples, nowadays something like 2300 remain, especially the 1975 powerful earthquake damaged and destroyed a lot of the temples. The area is not too small and not too big either, maybe measuring 10×10km, just big enough to find solitude and to explore the area just without any other soul around you and just small enough to do that on your own feet. To stroll around the fields, to climb various temples and to enjoy the view over the plain, maybe to stop at a temple for several hours, just you, a book and the impressing scenery around you, was one of the most amazing things I’ve ever done in my life. Additionally to this already impressing site, there was another big thing happening in this days. The longest lasting sun eclipse in history crossed Bagan on the 17th of january. Already in the days before Bagan began to become “crowded”, maybe more crowded than ever before. But we’re still talking in Myanmar numbers, a country that hardly sees 300000 tourists a year. Compared to Thailand (or Angkor Wat in Cambodia), it was still empty here. The afternoon of the 17th of January than finally offered perfect conditions for this natural highlight. There was no cloud in the blue sky, the obversation conditions couldn’t have been better. I was just about to enter the “Bad Luck Temple” when a very excited french man came up to me with his special sun eclipse glasses and told me that the sun eclipse just started. I didn’t believe him because there were usually more
than three hours left until the moon would cover the sun but a view through his glasses convinced me
. I hurried up to the temple that should be the meeting point with the other people from the guesthouse. It was still a few kilometers away, but at least when I arrived there I recognised that I was much to early. Even after the “first contact” it takes a few hours until the moon is in the middle of the sun. Myanmar was, as expected not really prepared for this sun eclipse, so it wasn’t possible to get these special glasses anywhere in the city except in the 5* hotels and they kept the glasses for their guests. Instead of glasses people used old x-rays, floppy discs or black and white photo film, what worked good, too. Tour groups that flew in for this event from Germany, France or the USA had their own special glasses, too, and were happy to give them away for some time. We actually used x-rays, what was practical for the cameras to take pictures, too. The moon should be in the middle of the sun for more than 8 minutes, that means that this eclipse was the longest in this planets history but I have to say it was not that spectacular as I hoped. It’s definitely great to witness such a rare phenomenom at a place like Bagan but I expected a little bit more. It was an annacular and not total sun eclipse, so the moon didn’t cover the whole sun and left a ring around. The advantage of this was, that it was possible to see the sun corona, the disadvantage was that it didn’t really get dark. Anyway, it was nice, but nothing I would travel thousands of kilometers for.
The day after the eclipse was the perfect day to eplore the really big temples. It seemed that all tourists, except me (and Johannes from Freiburg in Germany), left Bagan directly after the eclipse and I had even famous huge temples like the “Pyathada Paya” just for me for several hours (when the first other tourists arrived to watch the sunset from there, I left). It really was amazing. In the evening I left together with Johannes on the night bus to Mandalay… a not so nice city as you imagine when you hear the name.
Same Same, But Different…
Freitag, 15. Januar 2010The ground crew of AirAsia and the customs weren’t really bothered about my condition but of course I tried not to show off that I’m totally drunk what maybe didn’t work so well. Max had this great idea to buy some yellow plastic glasses with palms on the top in Bangkok and put these glasses on everybodys nose who crossed his way. Now that he flew home he gave me this glasses to continue with the fun and I started in the Airport already. Unfortunately the most people weren’t as ethusiastic about the glasses as I was but maybe it was just too early in the morning. Anyway, I got a few pictures and usually wanted pictures of the stewards and stewardesses, too, but I slept in in the same second as I took my seat. My direct neighbour woke me up when the airplane was back on the ground and almost empty already, I was the last person who left it. So I was the last person from this flight that got it’s luggage, too and I was the last person that left the airport building as well, at a time when the free shuttle offered from my guesthouse already left without me, thinking that there’s nobody more to come out. It was not a big deal, I now shared a regular taxi with three other Germans and one Israeli what was good fun, too. Our taxi
” driver was funny and free to talk about the situation and the government in his country and I got some “yellow glasses” pictures as well. Really a great thing, this yellow glasses and a great pity that I lost them already after two days… When we finally arrived at the guesthouse I just had the desire to sleep, what I did, for almost the whole day.
The next day I was fit again and it was time to get some first impressions in this country. Yangon has nearly 5 million inhabitants and is the biggest city in the country but not the capital anymore. The military generals, who are the men with the power there, decided in 2005 to switch the capital to Nay Pyi Taw (means “Royal Capital”), a city that didn’t exist before this decision and is in construction now. That’s where all the money goes to… but more about that later. I really liked Yangon from the first minutes I arrived there. It’s definitely something else here compared to the other big cities in South-East Asia. It feels a little bit as if you were thrown back into the eightis. The majority of the people still wears their traditional clothing (that is a skirt for men and woman, called “longyi” for men and “ingyi” for woman), you don’t see a lot of people with mobile phones, the streets aren’t very crowded (in asian dimensions) and the most people seem to live a pretty simple life. Of course, Yangon is the biggest city and the cultural and economical capital of the country and can find almost everything here that you can find in Germany or Thailand,
too, but you have to look out for these things, you don’t face them everywhere like in the rest of this globalised, standardised world. And one thing that I recognised very fast was, that the people in Yangon are very humourous and good for a laugh. When you see the condition their country is in you maybe have to be.
As a city itself, Yangon is a big mixture of missionary or colonial (that means christian), indian, bamar, muslim and modern western influences, that makes it to a big melting pot of cultures. You see people of all world religions on the street and some quarters have a destinctive flavour of India or others of China. Otherwise the city is definitely not a beauty and poverty, social mismanagement, a lack of infrastructure etc. is visible everywhere. Everything is said wenn I tell you that the government can’t manage it to provide enough electricity for their biggest and most developed city. Power cuts are very frequent, like 5-6 times a day, everytime for hours.
But for sure Yangon has the great sights that
” /> are a must see for every visitor in Myanmar, too. At first to mention is definitely the famous Shwedagon Paya, the most important buddhist pagoda in Myanmar. I visited the pagoda twice in one day, one time during the day and one time in the evening and for me it’s just a magical place. A place where you start to dream and where suddenly all questions if this kind of a travel lifestyle is worth all the inconveniences that come with it, are answered: Yes, it is! The Shwedagon Paya is not just one huge gold-glowing stupa (but it is, as well), around the main stupa there’s a big assortment of smaller stupas, statues, temples, shrines, images and pavillons and everything is coloured in this glowing orange gold – people say that the Shwedagon Paya holds more gold reserves than the whole Bank Of England. It’s one of these places where you have to remind yourself how privileged you are and thankfully you should be to see this because there are a lot of people who’s biggest dream it is to go to this place and for them it will just remain a dream. The Shwedagon Paya is maybe the most impressive, but by far not the only tourist attraction in the city, another example of a golden pagoda is the Sule Paya, it has it’s place in the middle of the biggest street roundabout in the city, very strange.
At all I spent three nights and four days in Yangon, mostly strolling around the city and occasionally visiting a temple or another tourist site and it was really a good time. The people here are really openminded and I somehow liked the athmosphere that flows through the, very often, dirty and smelly streets.
Burma / Myanmar – Going or Boycotting?
Donnerstag, 10. Dezember 2009
This is actually a serious question that everyone who is thinking about travelling to or in Burma has to answer himself and it’s actually not so easy to answer this question. I try to explain.
Why is this a question and how is Burma/Myanmar like?
Burma/Myanmar is a country of 47 million people that is ruled by a brutal military dictatorship since 1962, the longest still lasting military dictatorship on the planet. 500.000 soldiers (as many as 70,000 child soldiers – more than any other country in the world) back the whole system that is famous for inprisoning political “dissidents”, cracking down peaceful demonstrations, seizing foreign aid donations and cutting off the burmese people from the rest of the world. Nearly half of the government budget is spent on the military and just 0,15€ per person per year on health. Organisations like Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and other groups have repeatedly detailed long lists of human rights violations with cases of abuses, including murder, torture, rape, detention without trial, massive forced relocations, and forced labor in the country. There are not a lot countries who still have such a hardline government with so less freedom of speech, freedom of press and freedom of movement like Myanmar. Beside this country you can maybe mention North Korea, Eritrea, Turkmenistan and Cuba. Burmese people are not allowed to leave the country, a mobile phone sim-card costs about 1000US$ (not affordable for 99,9% of the people in Myanmar), internet connections are limited to 256kbs, to limit the number of users (only 0,1% of the population has internet access) and all media is controlled and dictated by the military. In situations like 2007, when peaceful demonstrations try to express the dissatisfection in the country, the government tends to cut off all internet access of the country for several days (just two governments in the world ever did that – Myanmar and Nepal) to ensure that as less as possible informations leave from and arrive in the country. Also the government refused foreign aid after Cyclone Nargis in May 2008 which caused 85.000 deaths in the Iddarwady Delta.
So, Burma is mostly governed by fear and no outsider is happy about the situation as it appears in this forgotten country today, that is clear, but the real question about it is how to handle this situation and how to support the people in the country?
The opinions vary…
Boycott Myanmar!
Most of the people who support the “Boycott Burma”-campaign see visitors as a symbolic stamp of approval for the Myanmar government and ask people to stay away from the country. Definitely, it’s true. You can’t visit Myanmar giving an approval to the military dictatorship. Already the visa you obtain will fill the pockets of the generals and will help them to ensure their dictatorship. The government used forced labour to build tourist infrastructure and services as well as the forced relocation of thousands of families to build hotels etc. Without any tourists, the government wouldn’t do that, that’s for sure. Some activist groups like the “Burma Campaign UK” claims that “almost all money goes to the regime’s pocket in one way or another” and they come out in favour of a total embargo (economically) of Myanmar to dry out the military dictatorship and their financial power. Another reason to stay away from Burma is maybe that Aung San Suu Kyi, the house arrested voice of the National League for Democracy, asked tourists not to come.
“Nowhere else in the world have human rights abuses and tourism been so closely linked.” Burma Campaign UK
Visit Burma!
The most people in Burma want you to come, inclusive veterans of the 1988 prodemocracy protests and argue that, if you spent your money carefully, 80% of your money will stay in the peoples hand and won’t go to the government. And this, the spreading of tourist money, is almost the only way to get money into the country without supporting the government. Bank transactions to Burma are not possible and all investments western companies do will go through the government and will support the government directly. The UK-based “Voices Of Burma”-campaign for example draws a clear line between tourism, that will have a positive effect and tourism, that will have a negative effect. “By accepting the standard boycott view we miss an important opportunity to help the Burmese people.” They promote staying at private guesthouses, travelling off-the-beaten track and ensuring that for every Dollar that goes to the government you should make sure to spent two in the private sector. But the protourism campaigns don’t only see a positive effect in tourism by bringing some money into the country, they see the very important point, that burmese people will have the possibility to talk to people from outside Myanmar. Locals see, that they are not forgotten and visitors take away images and stories that will be shared outside of Burma. Human rights violations also are less likely to occur in areas where international visitors are present.
But of course, the main question is, whether the money you bring is what keeps the junta in power. In days ago the government hoped that tourism will bring a huge source of hard currency into the country. It’s clear now that they’ve depended little on it. The absolute biggest part of their income is from the trade of gems, timber, textiles and, most notably, oil and gas (Myanmar receives, at most, 0,7% of their GDP from tourism, calculated by CIA statistics). And that’s something the European Union, the USA or other countries and companies should take care about, people can’t change that by themselves.
“Isolation is the regime’s default condition. It is what fuels the present system. Burma might not become a democracy overnight, but it will certainly improve with more outside interaction. Would Indonesia be better off if no one had visited during its 30 years of military rule?”
Thant Myint-U, author of “River of Lost Foot Steps”, on the boycott of Burma/Myanmar
My decision:
Beside all that stuff above, of course, personal interests play a role in all the thoughts as well. My world travels are named “The No Planes Project” and I want to travel around the world without taking an airplane. I would have to take an airplane to get into Myanmar, as all roads from the border crossings into the country are closed for foreigners (as many other roads are as well). Flying from Bangkok to Rangoon and back will be the only option.
Another point is, that I’m really interested in the country and the military dictatorship. Not in a way of sensation tourism or something like that, but in general I’m very interested in politics and I think it will be a very educational and interesting visit for me.
I will go to Myanmar.
In my opinion, I think it’s good to visit the country. The best example of this I see every day in the country where I am at the moment: Vietnam. Off limit to visitors and isolated to the rest of the world 20 years ago, it’s an open-minded country with open people nowadays (ok, there is still a communist dictatorship here and no freedom of press, but people can leave the country and they have uncensored internet access, access to foreign media and books, can interact with foreign people etc., at all it feels relatively free here).
I hope to talk to people in Myanmar, to tell them about the world outside and to learn something I can take with me and tell other people around the world. I hope to create at least a little public (for example with this blog) and open some eyes for the situation and the people there.
P.S.: I don’t see the “No Planes Project” as over. The flights (just one hour in each direction) from Bangkok to Rangoon and back don’t bring me forward one single meter and it’s the only legal way to enter the country – overland travel is just not possible, and somehow my principle of taking no flights isn’t as important for me as the experience Burma, especially in this case.
further information:
Burma Campaign UK
Free Burma Coalition
